How to read a USPTO office action, work the deadline, and decide which refusals are worth a fight

11/16/26

The email from the USPTO has a subject line only a government agency could love. The letter runs four pages (or more!). Most applicants read the first paragraph, see the word “refused,” and figure the application is a lost cause. It usually isn’t. An office action is the Examining Attorney’s summary and report of everything standing between your application and a trademark registration.

Sometimes, it is simply a requirement or two. Other times it is a substantive refusal.  The first task is to figure out which one you have – or if you have both!

 

First Step: Find the Deadline

Before you read anything else, find the response date. Most applications filed under Section 1 or Section 44 get three months from the mailing date of the Office Action. Applications filed via the Madrid Protocol get six months of the mailing date but finding that date can be tricky. You can always check the date at the USPTO’s website (www.tsdr.uspto.gov) and enter in your application serial number. Click on the Document tab and for Madrid applications, use the date for the “IB-1rst Refusal Note.”

Miss this deadline and the application is abandoned, but it can be revived for an additional fee. Put your deadline on a calendar more than one person watches.

 

Requirements versus Substantive Refusals

Requirements: This means that you need to make some changes to the information that you included in your application. A description of goods that is indefinite and needs to be modified. A descriptive word that should be disclaimed. An entity type that needs clarification. The Examining Attorney usually provides you with the information needed for you to make the proper amendments.

Substantive Refusals: This is different – this means that there is either an issue with the mark itself (for example, it is viewed as descriptive – under Section 2(e)(1)) or there is an issue because it is viewed as confusingly similar to one (or more) prior registered trademarks – under Section 2(d).

The most common substantive refusals are:

Likelihood of Confusion under Section 2(d): The Examining Attorney conducted a search and found a trademark registration (or several) that they determined to be sufficiently similar to yours for related goods or service, and thinks consumers would be confused and assume they connected or related in some way.

 

Merely Descriptive under Section 2(e)(1). The Examining Attorney conducted research and believed your mark merely describes a feature, function or purpose of your product or service.

 

Preparing Arguments

Some refusals are worth the argument – here are some questions that may help you decide.

For a 2(d) refusal: How close are the marks and the goods and services – are the latter in the same class or classes? Check the other mark – is the registrant still using it? How broadly did you file – is it possible to amend your identification to narrow it to remove the overlap?

For a 2(e)(1) refusal: Does the name take a second of thought to connect to the product or service, or does it immediately describe the product or service? Have you begun using the mark?

Regardless, if you decide to file a response, make sure you answer every refusal and/or requirement in the Office Action, preferably in the order they are laid out. Skip one small requirement and the Examining Attorney will make that requirement final.

 

After the Response is Filed

If the Examining Attorney is persuaded by your arguments, they will withdraw the refusal(s) and accept the responses to the requirements. The next step is publication of your mark and you are on your way to registration! If the Examining Attorney does not accept any one or combination of your response submissions, you will either receive a Final Office Action or a Second Non-Final Office Action. At that point, you can still prepare further arguments, which could include a Request for Reconsideration and/or  an appeal to the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.

A first office action is an opening move. Read it closely, answer every point, and pick your fights. That gives your application its best shot.

 

Received an office action? Send it to Markery Law before the clock runs down.